Fluent, Inc. - Quarter Report: 2023 September (Form 10-Q)

PART I - FINANCIAL INFORMATION

Unless otherwise indicated or required by the context, all references in this Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q to "we," "us," "our," "Fluent," or the "Company," refer to Fluent, Inc. and its consolidated subsidiaries.

ITEM 1. FINANCIAL STATEMENTS.

FLUENT, INC.

CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

See notes to consolidated financial statements

FLUENT, INC.

CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

See notes to consolidated financial statements

FLUENT, INC.

CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CHANGES IN SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

See notes to consolidated financial statements

FLUENT, INC.

CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS

(Amounts in thousands)

(unaudited)

See notes to consolidated financial statements

FLUENT, INC.

NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

1. Summary of significant accounting policies

(a) Basis of preparation 

The accompanying unaudited consolidated financial statements have been prepared by Fluent, Inc., a Delaware corporation (the "Company" or "Fluent"), in accordance with accounting principles generally accepted in the United States ("GAAP") and applicable rules and regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission (the "SEC") regarding interim financial reporting. Certain information and note disclosures normally included in annual financial statements prepared in accordance with GAAP have been condensed or omitted pursuant to those rules and regulations.

The accompanying unaudited consolidated financial statements reflect all normal recurring adjustments necessary to present fairly the financial position, results of operations, and cash flows for the interim periods ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, respectively, but are not necessarily indicative of the results of operations to be anticipated for any future interim periods or for the full year ending December 31, 2023.

From time to time, the Company may enter into relationships or investments with other entities, and, in certain instances, the entity in which the Company has a relationship or investment may qualify as a variable interest entity ("VIE"). The Company consolidates a VIE in its financial statements if the Company is deemed to be the primary beneficiary of the VIE. The primary beneficiary is the party that has the power to direct activities that most significantly impact the operations of the VIE and has the obligation to absorb losses or the right to benefits from the VIE that could potentially be significant to the VIE. 

The information included in this Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q should be read in conjunction with the consolidated financial statements and accompanying notes included in the Company's Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended  December 31, 2022 ("2022 Form 10-K") filed with the SEC on March 15, 2023. The consolidated balance sheet as of  December 31, 2022 included herein was derived from the audited financial statements as of that date and included in the 2022 Form 10-K.

Going concern

In accordance with ASC 205-40, Presentation of Financial Statements – Going Concern, management must evaluate whether there are conditions and events, considered in the aggregate, that raise substantial doubt about the Company’s ability to continue as a going concern for one year after the date these accompanying unaudited financial statements are issued (the “issuance date”). As part of this evaluation, management may consider the potential mitigating impact of its plans that have not been fully implemented as of the issuance date if (a) it is probable that management’s plans will be effectively implemented on a timely basis, and (b) it is probable that the plans, when implemented, will alleviate the relevant conditions or events that raise substantial doubt about the Company’s ability to continue as a going concern within one year after the issuance date.

The Company has experienced a decline in its operating results, driven primarily by the continued economic slowdown and uncertainty, as well as the impacts of the recently imposed regulatory requirements (see Note 10, Contingencies). As a result, as of  September 30, 2023, the Company was not in compliance with the total leverage ratio covenant under its Credit Agreement (see Note 5, Long-term debt, net) and such event of default continued until the Waiver (defined below) became effective. The Company has also projected a continued decline in its operating results, driven primarily by the same factors described above. Therefore, the Company does not expect to be in compliance with certain financial covenants under the Credit Agreement during certain quarters in the twelve months following the issuance date. If the Company is not in compliance with its covenants, under the Credit Agreement, it will be an event of default that would give lenders the right to accelerate maturities under the Credit Agreement. While the Company had cash and cash equivalents of $20.5 million as of  September 30, 2023  and had positive cash flow from operations in the prior two fiscal years and for the nine months ended September 30, 2023, management does not expect the Company’s cash resources would be adequate to meet its obligations as they become due within the one-year period after the issuance date if maturities under the Credit Agreement were accelerated. These circumstances raise substantial doubt about the Company’s ability to continue as a going concern.

As discussed in Note 5, Long-term debt, net, on November 15, 2023, Fluent, LLC (the “Borrower”) entered into a Temporary Waiver Under Credit Agreement (the “Waiver”) to the Credit Agreement that is effective through the earlier of January 15, 2024 or an occurrence of any other event of default (the “Termination date”). In addition to temporarily waiving the event of default resulting from the breach of the total leverage ratio covenant during the three months ended September 30, 2023, the Waiver imposed new financial reporting obligations on the Borrower, including the delivery of the Company’s 2024 budget by November 22, 2023 for review by the business consultant retained by counsel to Citizens Bank. The Company intends for that budget to inform modified financial covenant levels and other provisions, as appropriate, for the quarters ending December 31, 2023 through December 31, 2024, which would be accomplished with an amendment to the Credit Agreement. The Borrower and Citizens Bank have previously entered into amendments to the Credit Agreement as needed, and management expects to be able to enter into a new amendment prior to the Termination date.

In light of the recent challenges the Company has faced in achieving its financial targets, the Company plans to implement cost reductions and focus resources on new growth opportunities that will enable the Company to meet its projected budget.

While management believes its plans to enter into a new amendment to the Credit Agreement with financial covenant levels that the Company can satisfy will alleviate the conditions or events that raise substantial doubt about the Company’s ability to continue as a going concern, successfully entering into it is not entirely within the Company’s control. In addition, there is no guarantee that the planned cost reductions or growth opportunities will be successfully executed or have the expected benefits. As there can be no assurance that the Company will be able to effectively implement its plans within one year after the issuance date, based on the factors above, management concluded that there is substantial doubt about the Company's ability to continue as a going concern through such one-year period.

The accompanying unaudited financial statements do not include any adjustments relating to the possible future effects on the recoverability and classification of recorded assets and classification of liabilities that might result should the Company be unable to continue as a going concern.

Principles of consolidation

The consolidated financial statements include the financial statements of the Company and its subsidiaries. All significant transactions among the Company and its subsidiaries have been eliminated upon consolidation.

(b) Recently issued and adopted accounting standards

Accounting pronouncements not listed below were assessed and determined to be not applicable or are expected to have minimal impact on the Company's consolidated financial statements.

In January 2016, the Financial Accounting Standards Board issued Accounting Standards Updates No. 2016-13, Financial Instruments—Credit Losses and additional changes, modifications, clarifications, or interpretations thereafter, which require a reporting entity to estimate credit losses on certain types of financial instruments, and present assets held at amortized cost and available-for-sale debt securities at the amounts expected to be collected. The new guidance was effective for annual and interim periods beginning after December 15, 2022, and early adoption was permitted. The Company completed its assessment of the new guidance and determined it had no material impact on its consolidated financial statements.

FLUENT, INC.

NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (CONTINUED)

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

(c) Revenue recognition

Revenue is generated when control of goods or services is transferred to customers, in the amounts that reflect the consideration the Company expects to be entitled to in exchange for those goods or services. The Company's performance obligation is typically to (a) deliver data records based on predefined qualifying characteristics specified by the customer, (b) generate conversions based on predefined user actions (for example, a click, a registration or the installation of an app) and subject to certain qualifying characteristics specified by the customer, (c) verify user interest or transfer calls to advertiser clients as a part of the contact center operation, or (d) deliver media spend as a part of the business of AdParlor, LLC, a wholly-owned subsidiary of the Company.

Revenue is recognized upon satisfaction of the associated performance obligation. The Company elected the "right to invoice" practical expedient under Accounting Standards Codification ("ASC") 606-10-55-18 as a measure for revenue to be recognized, as it corresponds directly with the amounts that reflects the consideration the Company expects to be entitled to in exchange for those goods or services.

When there is a delay between the period in which revenue is recognized and when a customer invoice is issued, revenue is earned, and the related amounts are recorded as unbilled revenue within accounts receivable on the consolidated balance sheets. As of  September 30, 2023 and December 31, 2022, unbilled revenue included in accounts receivable was $23,374 and $26,878, respectively. In line with industry practice, the unbilled revenue balance is recorded based on the Company's internally tracked conversions, net of estimated variances between this amount and the amount tracked and subsequently confirmed by customers. Substantially all amounts included within the unbilled revenue balance are invoiced to customers within the month directly following the period of service. Historical estimates related to unbilled revenue have not been materially different from actual revenue billed.

(d) Use of estimates

The preparation of consolidated financial statements in accordance with GAAP requires the Company’s management to make estimates and assumptions relating to the reported amounts of assets and liabilities, the disclosure of contingent assets and liabilities at the date of the consolidated financial statements, and the reported amounts of revenue and expenses during the reporting periods. Significant items subject to such estimates and assumptions include the allowance for doubtful accounts, useful lives of intangible assets, recoverability of the carrying amounts of goodwill and intangible assets, the portion of revenue subject to estimates for variances between internally-tracked conversions and those confirmed by the customer, purchase accounting, valuation of variable interest entity, accruals for contingencies, and income tax provisions. These estimates are often based on complex judgments and assumptions that management believes to be reasonable but are inherently uncertain and unpredictable. Actual results could differ from these estimates.

(e) Fair value

Fair value is defined as the exchange price that would be received for an asset or paid to transfer a liability (an exit price) in the principal or most advantageous market for the asset or liability in an orderly transaction between market participants on the measurement date.

Valuation techniques used to measure fair value must maximize the use of observable inputs and minimize the use of unobservable inputs. Accounting standards describe a fair value hierarchy based on the following three levels of inputs, of which the first two are considered observable and the last unobservable, that may be used to measure fair value:

FLUENT, INC.

NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (CONTINUED)

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

The fair value of the Company’s cash, cash equivalents, accounts receivable, accounts payable and accrued liabilities approximate their carrying values because of the short-term nature of these instruments.

As of September 30, 2023, the Company regards the fair value of its long-term debt to approximate its carrying value. The fair value assessment represents a Level 2 measurement. See Note 5, Long-term debt, net.

The fair value of certain long-lived non-financial assets and liabilities may be required to be measured on a nonrecurring basis in certain circumstances, including when there is evidence of impairment. As of September 30, 2023, certain non-financial assets have been measured at fair value subsequent to their initial recognition. The Company determined the estimated fair value to be a Level 3 measurement, as certain inputs used to determine fair value are unobservable. See Note 4, Goodwill, for further discussion of impairment charges.

2. Income (loss) per share

Basic income (loss) per share is computed by dividing net income (loss) by the weighted average number of common shares outstanding during the period, in addition to restricted stock units ("RSUs") that are vested but not delivered. Diluted income (loss) per share reflects the potential dilution that could occur if securities or other contracts to issue common stock are exercised or converted into common stock and is calculated using the treasury stock method for stock options, restricted stock units, restricted stock, warrants and deferred common stock. Stock equivalent shares are excluded from the calculation in loss periods, as their effects would be anti-dilutive.

For the three and nine months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, basic and diluted income (loss) per share were as follows:

Based on exercise prices compared to the average stock prices for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, certain stock equivalents, including restricted stock units and stock options, have been excluded from the diluted weighted average share calculations due to their anti-dilutive nature.

FLUENT, INC.

NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (CONTINUED)

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

3. Intangible assets, net

Intangible assets, net, other than goodwill, consist of the following: 

The gross amounts associated with software developed for internal use primarily represent capitalized costs of internally developed software. The amounts relating to acquired proprietary technology, customer relationships, trade names, domain names, databases and non-competition agreements primarily represent the fair values of intangible assets acquired as a result of the acquisition of Fluent, LLC, effective December 8, 2015 (the "Fluent, LLC Acquisition"); the acquisition of Q Interactive, LLC, effective June 8, 2016 (the "Q Interactive Acquisition"); the acquisition of substantially all the assets of AdParlor Holdings, Inc. and certain of its affiliates, effective July 1, 2019 (the "AdParlor Acquisition"); the acquisition of a 50% interest in Winopoly, LLC (the "Initial Winopoly Acquisition"), effective April 1, 2020; the acquisition of a 100% interest in True North Loyalty, LLC, (the "True North Acquisition"), effective January 1, 2022 (see Note 11, Business acquisition), and the consolidation of TAPP Influencers Corp. ("TAPP") effective January 9, 2023 (see Note 12, Variable Interest Entity).

FLUENT, INC.

NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (CONTINUED)

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

During the second quarter of 2023, the Company determined that the effects of the recently imposed regulatory requirements on the Company constituted a triggering event. The Company also then determined that the decline in the market value of its publicly traded stock, which resulted in a corresponding decline in its market capitalization, along with the operating results for the third quarter of 2023, also constituted a triggering event. The Company conducted an interim test of the recoverability of its long-lived assets, which compared projected undiscounted cash flows to the carrying value of the asset group. The results of this approach indicated that its long-lived assets were not impaired as of  June 30, 2023 or  September 30, 2023.

Amortization expenses of $2,559 and $3,292 for the three months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, respectively, and $7,810 and $9,651 for the nine months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, respectively, are included in depreciation and amortization expenses in the consolidated statements of operations. As of September 30, 2023, intangible assets with a carrying amount of $919, included in the gross amount of software developed for internal use, have not commenced amortization, as they are not ready for their intended use.

As of September 30, 2023, estimated amortization expenses related to the Company's intangible assets for the remainder of 2023 and through 2028 and thereafter are as follows:

4. Goodwill

Goodwill represents the difference between the purchase price and the estimated fair value of net assets acquired, when accounted for under business combination accounting. As of September 30, 2023, the total balance of goodwill was $1,261, a decrease of $53,850 from December 31, 2022, as a result of a non-cash impairment charge of $55,405, offset by a 1,555 increase in goodwill related to the TAPP consolidation, which was within the non-cash impairment charge (see Note 12, Variable Interest Entities). The balance also relates to the Fluent LLC Acquisition, the Q Interactive Acquisition, the AdParlor Acquisition, the Initial Winopoly Acquisition, and the True North Acquisition (see Note 11, Business acquisition).

In accordance with ASC 350, Intangibles - Goodwill and Other, goodwill is assessed at least annually for impairment, or when events or changes in circumstances indicate that the carrying amount of such assets may not be recoverable, by assessing qualitative factors or performing a quantitative analysis in determining whether it is more likely than not that its fair value exceeds the carrying value. The measurement date of the Company's annual goodwill impairment test is set to October 1.

For the three months ended March 31, 2023, the Company completed its quarterly triggering event assessments and determined that the decline in the market value of its publicly-traded stock, which resulted in a corresponding decline in its market capitalization, constituted a triggering event. The Company therefore conducted an interim test of the fair value of the Fluent reporting unit's goodwill for potential impairment as of March 31, 2023. The Company considered a combination of income and market approaches to determine the fair value of the Fluent reporting unit. The Company determined that a market-based approach, which considered the Company’s implied market multiple applied to management’s forecast and further adjusted for a control premium, provided the best indication of fair value of the Fluent reporting unit. The results of this market-based approach indicated that the Fluent reporting unit’s carrying value exceeded its fair value by 20%. The Company therefore concluded that the Fluent reporting unit’s goodwill of $51,614 was impaired and recorded a non-cash impairment charge of $25,700.

FLUENT, INC.

NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (CONTINUED)

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

For the three months ended June 30, 2023, the Company completed its quarterly triggering event assessments and determined that the effect of the recently imposed regulatory requirements and the effect of the continued economic slowdown on the Company’s expected operating results had each constituted a triggering event. The Company therefore conducted an interim test of the fair value of the Fluent reporting unit's goodwill for potential impairment related to both triggering events as of  June 30, 2023. The Company applied a combination of income and market approaches to determine the fair value of the Fluent reporting unit. The results of this approach indicated that the fair value exceeded its carrying value by 5%. The Company therefore concluded that the Fluent reporting unit’s goodwill of $27,469 was not impaired.

For the three months ended September 30, 2023, the Company completed its quarterly triggering event assessments and determined that the decline in the market value of its publicly-traded stock, which resulted in a corresponding decline in its market capitalization, along with the impact of the continued economic slowdown on the Company’s expected operating results had both constituted a triggering event. The Company therefore conducted an interim test of the fair value of the Fluent reporting unit's goodwill for potential impairment related to both triggering events and All Others for potential impairment related to the economic slowdown. The Company applied a combination of income and market approaches to determine the fair value of the Fluent reporting unit and All Others. The results of this approach indicated that the Fluent reporting unit’s carrying value and All Others carrying value exceeded its fair value by 32% and 29%, respectively. The Company therefore concluded that the Fluent reporting unit’s goodwill was impaired and recorded a non-cash impairment for the remainder of the goodwill balance of $27,469. In addition, the All Other goodwill of $3,497 was also concluded to be impaired, and the Company recorded a non-cash impairment charge of $2,236.

5. Long-term debt, net

Long-term debt, net of unamortized discount and financing costs, related to the Credit Facility consisted of the following:

Credit Facility

On March 31, 2021, Fluent, LLC (the "Borrower") entered into a credit agreement (as amended, modified, extended, restated, replaced, or supplemented from time to time, the "Credit Agreement") with certain subsidiaries of the Borrower as guarantors, the lenders thereto, and Citizens Bank, N.A. ("Citizens Bank") as administrative agent, lead arranger and bookrunner. The original Credit Agreement provided for a term loan in the aggregate principal amount of $50,000 funded on the closing date (the "Term Loan"), along with an undrawn revolving credit facility of up to $15,000 (the "Revolving Loans," and together with the Term Loan, the "Credit Facility"). 

On May 15, 2023, the Borrower and Citizens Bank entered into a third amendment to the Credit Agreement, which amended certain provisions by adding an additional tier of applicable margin to the selected rates and providing for additional notice of certain material events and, for the remaining fiscal quarters of 2023, established the following, in each case pursuant to the terms and conditions under the Credit Agreement: (i) adjustments to the pricing floor and certain EBITDA add-backs; (ii) monthly financial reporting requirements; (iii) additional financial covenant testing conditions on Fluent’s ability to draw on the Revolving Loans; (iv) additional tiers to certain financial covenants and added a minimum cash liquidity financial covenant; (v) additional restrictions on the ability to (a) make loans and advances to officers, directors and employees; (b) invest in certain subsidiaries and joint ventures; and (c) make additional loans, investments or permitted acquisitions; and (vi) additional unrestricted cash requirements before the Company is permitted to pay dividends, make distributions or redeem or repurchase equity interests.

FLUENT, INC.

NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (CONTINUED)

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

On August 21, 2023, the Borrower and Citizens Bank entered into a fourth amendment to the Credit Agreement (the “Fourth Amendment”), which (i) adjusted certain financial covenants for the remaining fiscal quarters of 2023, including prohibiting the Company from drawing on the Revolving Loans until the issuance of the December 31, 2023 annual financial statements, (ii) temporarily adjusted interest rates, (iii) permitted Citizens Bank to retain a business consultant at the Borrower's expense to advise on the credit parties’ financial and operating performance; (iv) required weekly liquidity reports to Citizens Bank, and (v) required a $5,000 prepayment of the Term Loan and a reduction in the maximum amount of the Revolving Loans by the same amount to $10,000. The $5,000 prepayment amount was paid as of  September 30, 2023. In evaluating the amendments under ASC 470-50, Debt- Modifications and Extinguishments, the Company determined that the amendment should be treated as a debt modification with no gain or loss recognized.

On November 15, 2023, the Borrower and Citizens Bank entered into a Waiver to the Credit Agreement, pursuant to which Citizens Bank agreed to waive through the Termination date its rights and remedies arising from the Company’s breach of the total leverage ratio covenant during the quarter ending September 30, 2023.  The Waiver also added new reporting requirements, temporarily increased the applicable margin, and extended the term of the business consultant through January 15, 2024.  The Borrower must also provide a 2024 budget that has been reviewed by the business consultant retained by counsel to Citizens Bank. The Company intends for that budget to inform modified financial covenant levels and other provisions, as appropriate, for the quarters ending December 31, 2023 through December 31, 2024, which would be accomplished with an amendment to the Credit Agreement.

All obligations under the the Credit Agreement currently mature on  March 31, 2026, and interest is payable monthly. Scheduled principal amortization of the Term Loan is $1,250 per quarter, which commenced with the fiscal quarter ended June 30, 2021. At September 30, 2023, the Company was in compliance with all of the financial covenants under the Credit Agreement except for the total leverage ratio covenant. As discussed above, this covenant breach was waived through the Termination date by the Waiver. However, based on projections, the Company does not expect to be in compliance with certain financial covenants during certain quarters in the next twelve months. If the Company is not in compliance with financial covenants, it will be an event of default that would give the lenders the right to accelerate maturities.  Accordingly, all borrowings under the Credit Agreement have been classified as current as of September 30, 2023.

Borrowings under the Credit Agreement bear interest at a rate per annum equal to the benchmark selected by the Borrower, which may be based on the Alternative Base Rate, (as defined in the Credit Agreement), LIBOR (as defined in the Credit Agreement) rate (subject to a floor of 0.25%) prior to the election as of December 31, 2022 or Term SOFR (as defined in the Credit Agreement) (subject to a floor of 0.00%) subsequent to the election, plus a margin applicable to the selected benchmark. The applicable margin is between 0.75% and 2.25% for borrowings based on the Alternative Base Rate and 1.75% and 3.25% for borrowings based on Term SOFR, depending upon the Borrower's total leverage ratio. The opening interest rate of the Credit Facility was 2.50% (LIBOR + 2.25%), which increased to 8.92% (Term SOFR + 0.1% + 3.50%) as of September 30, 2023.

The Credit Agreement also contains certain customary conditions applicable to extensions of credit, including that representations and warranties made in the Credit Agreement be materially true and correct at the time of such extension (once such extensions are no longer prohibited by the Fourth Amendment or a later amendment). 

Maturities

As of September 30, 2023, scheduled future maturities of the Credit Agreement are as follows, reflective of the debt being accelerated as of the termination date if a new amendment is not reached:

FLUENT, INC.

NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (CONTINUED)

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

6. Income taxes

The Company is subject to federal and state income taxes in the United States. The tax provision for interim periods is determined using an estimate of the Company's annual effective tax rate ("AETR"). The Company updates its estimated AETR on a quarterly basis and, if the estimate changes, a cumulative adjustment is made. 

As of  September 30, 2023 and December 31, 2022, the Company recorded a full valuation allowance against net deferred tax assets and intends to continue maintaining a full valuation allowance on these net deferred tax assets until there is sufficient evidence to support the release of all or a portion of these allowances. Release of some or all of the valuation allowance would result in the recognition of certain deferred tax assets and an increase in deferred tax benefit for any period in which such a release may be recorded. However, the exact timing and amount of any valuation allowance release are subject to change, depending upon the level of profitability that the Company is able to achieve and the net deferred tax assets available.

For the nine months ended September 30, 2023, the Company's effective income tax expense rate of 0.9% differed from the statutory federal income tax rate of 21% primarily due to the projected federal and state cash tax expense expected to result in taxable income for full-year 2023 after the impact of a non-deductible goodwill impairment against pre-tax year-to-date losses, offset by the benefit of federal research and development credits. For the nine months ended September 30, 2022, the Company's effective income tax expense rate of 4.0% differed from the statutory federal income tax rate of 21% primarily due to the projected federal and state cash tax expense expected to result in taxable income for full-year 2022 after the impact of a non-deductible goodwill impairment against pre-tax year-to-date losses, offset by the benefit of federal research and development credits.

The Company assesses its income tax positions and records tax benefits for all years subject to examination based upon its evaluation of the facts, circumstances, and information available as of the reporting dates. For those tax positions where it is more-likely-than-not that a tax benefit will be sustained, the Company has recorded the largest amount of tax benefit with a greater than 50% likelihood of being realized upon ultimate settlement with a taxing authority that has full knowledge of all relevant information. For those income tax positions where it is not more-likely-than-not that a tax benefit will be sustained, no tax benefit has been recognized in the Company's financial statements.

As of  September 30, 2023 and December 31, 2022, the balance of unrecognized tax benefits was $1,480. The unrecognized tax benefits, if sustained, would benefit the Company's tax provision. As of September 30, 2023, the Company has not accrued any interest or penalties with respect to its uncertain tax positions.

The Company does not anticipate a significant increase or reduction in unrecognized tax benefits within the next twelve months.

7. Common stock, treasury stock and warrants

Common stock

As of  September 30, 2023 and December 31, 2022, the number of issued shares of common stock was 85,803,727 and 84,385,458, respectively, which included shares of treasury stock of 4,611,569 and 4,300,152, respectively.

For the nine months ended September 30, 2023, the change in the number of issued shares of common stock was the result of an aggregate 1,418,269 shares of common stock issued upon vesting of RSUs, including 311,417 shares of common stock withheld to cover statutory taxes upon such vesting, which are reflected in treasury stock, as discussed below.

Treasury stock

As of  September 30, 2023 and December 31, 2022, the Company held shares of treasury stock of 4,611,569 and 4,300,152, respectively, with a cost of $11,407 and $11,171, respectively.

FLUENT, INC.

NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (CONTINUED)

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

The Company's share-based incentive plans allow employees the option to either make cash payment or forfeit shares of common stock upon vesting to satisfy federal and state statutory tax withholding obligations associated with equity awards. The forfeited shares of common stock may be taken into treasury stock by the Company or sold on the open market. For the nine months ended September 30, 2023, 311,417 shares of common stock were withheld to cover statutory taxes owed by certain employees for this purpose, all of which were taken into treasury stock. See Note 8, Share-based compensation. 

8. Share-based compensation

On June 8, 2022, the stockholders of the Company approved the Fluent, Inc. 2022 Omnibus Equity Incentive Plan (the "2022 Plan") that authorized for issuance 15,422,523 shares of the Company's common stock. As of September 30, 2023, the Company had 5,598,650 shares of common stock available for grants pursuant to the 2022 Plan, which includes 946,071 shares of common stock previously available for issuance under the 2018 Stock Incentive Plan. 

The primary purpose of the 2022 Plan and prior plans is to attract, retain, reward, and motivate certain individuals by providing them with opportunities to acquire or increase their ownership interests in the Company. In October 2022, the Company issued to certain of its senior officers and employees, restricted stock units ("RSUs") (time-based vesting), long-term incentive grants (performance and time-based vesting RSUs), or performance share units ("PSUs") (achievement of performance targets settled in cash) under the 2022 Plan.

Stock options

The Compensation Committee of the Company's Board of Directors approved the grant of stock options to certain Company executives, which were issued on February 1, 2019, December 20, 2019,  March 1, 2020, and March 1, 2021. Subject to continuing service, 50% of the shares subject to these stock options will vest if the Company's stock price remains above 125.00%, 133.33%, 133.33% and 133.33%, respectively, of the exercise price for 20 consecutive trading days, and the remaining 50% of the shares subject to these stock options will vest if the Company's stock price remains above 156.25%, 177.78%, 177.78% and 177.78%, respectively, of the exercise price for 20 consecutive trading days; provided, that no shares will vest prior to the first anniversary of the grant date. As of September 30, 2023, the first condition for the stock options issued on February 1, 2019, December 20, 2019 and March 1, 2020 had been met and the second condition for the stock options issued on December 20, 2019 and March 1, 2020 had been met. Any shares that remain unvested as of the fifth anniversary of the grant date will vest in full on such date. The fair value of the stock options granted was estimated at the trading day before the date of grant using a Monte Carlo simulation model. The key assumptions utilized to calculate the grant-date fair values for these awards are summarized below:

FLUENT, INC.

NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (CONTINUED)

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

For the nine months ended September 30, 2023, details of stock option activity were as follows:

The aggregate intrinsic value amounts in the table above represent the difference between the closing price of the Company's common stock at the end of the reporting period and the corresponding exercise prices, multiplied by the number of in-the-money stock options as of the same date.

For the nine months ended September 30, 2023, the unvested balance of stock options was as follows:

Compensation expense recognized for stock options of $0 and $0 for the three months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, respectively, and $0 and $125 for the nine months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, respectively, was recorded in sales and marketing, product development and general and administrative expenses in the consolidated statements of operations. As of September 30, 2023, there was $0 of unrecognized share-based compensation with respect to outstanding stock options.

FLUENT, INC.

NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (CONTINUED)

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

Restricted stock units and restricted stock

For the nine months ended September 30, 2023, details of unvested RSU activity were as follows:

Compensation expense recognized for RSUs of $982 and $818 for the three months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, respectively, and $3,090 and $2,595 for the nine months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, respectively, was recorded in sales and marketing, product development and general and administrative in the consolidated statements of operations, and intangible assets, net in the consolidated balance sheets. The fair value of the RSUs and restricted stock was estimated using the closing prices of the Company's common stock on the dates of grant.

As of September 30, 2023, unrecognized share-based compensation expense associated with the granted RSUs and stock options amounted to $4,757, which is expected to be recognized over a weighted average period of 1.3 years.

For the three and nine months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, share-based compensation for the Company's stock options, RSUs, and common stock awards were allocated to the following accounts in the consolidated financial statements:

As of September 30, 2023, the Company recorded a liability of $15 related to PSUs that are to be settled in cash.

FLUENT, INC.

NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (CONTINUED)

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

9. Segment information

The Company identifies operating segments as components of an entity for which discrete financial information is available and is regularly reviewed by the chief operating decision maker ("CODM") in making decisions regarding resource allocation and performance assessment. The profitability measure employed by CODM is earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization ("EBITDA"). As of September 30, 2023, the Company had two operating segments with two corresponding reporting units, "Fluent" and "All Other," and one reportable segment. "Fluent," for the purposes of segment reporting, represents the consolidated operating results of the Company excluding "All Other." "All Other" represents the operating results of AdParlor, LLC and is included for purposes of reconciliation of the respective balances below to the consolidated financial statements.

Summarized financial information concerning the Company's segments for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022 are shown in the following tables below:

(1) Revenue aggregation is based upon location of the customer.

FLUENT, INC.

NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (CONTINUED)

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

As of September 30, 2023, long-lived assets are all located in the United States.

For the nine months ended  September 30, 2023, the Company identified an international customer within the Fluent segment with revenue in the amount of $47,658 which represents 21% of consolidated revenue.

10. Contingencies

In the ordinary course of business, the Company is subject to loss contingencies that cover a range of matters. An estimated loss from a loss contingency, such as a legal proceeding or claim, is accrued if it is probable that a liability has been incurred and the amount of the loss can be reasonably estimated. In determining whether a loss should be accrued, the Company evaluates, among other factors, the degree of probability and the ability to reasonably estimate the amount of any such loss. The Company does not accrue liabilities when the likelihood that the liability has been incurred is probable, but the amount cannot be reasonably estimated.

On March 31, 2022, the Company reached a settlement for $1,700 with the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance (the "Tax Department") following a sales and use tax audit covering the period from December 1, 2010 to November 30, 2019. The Tax Department had asserted that revenue derived from certain of the Company’s customer acquisition and list management services were subject to sales tax, as a result of being deemed taxable information services. The settlement amount was paid on April 1, 2022. Since March 1, 2022, the Company has been collecting and remitting New York sales tax on certain types of revenue from New York-based clients.

On January 28, 2020, Fluent received a Civil Investigative Demand from the Federal Trade Commission ("FTC") regarding compliance with the FTC Act and the Telemarketing Sales Rule. On October 18, 2022, the FTC staff sent the Company a draft complaint and proposed consent order seeking injunctive relief and a civil monetary penalty. On January 12, 2023, the Company made an initial proposal of $5,000 for the civil monetary penalty contingent on successful negotiation of the remaining outstanding injunctions and other provisions. The Company accrued the same amount for the year ending December 31, 2022. On  May 26, 2023, Fluent agreed to the terms of a Stipulated Order for Permanent Injunction, Monetary Judgment, Civil Penalty Judgment, and Other Relief (the "FTC Consent Order"). The FTC Consent Order imposed a civil penalty of $2,500, required additional changes to the Company’s employment opportunities marketplace and programmatic advertising business, and resulted in the implementation of compliance measures across the business. The same day, Fluent transferred the amount of the civil penalty to a third-party escrow account. On July 17, 2023, the FTC filed its Complaint for Civil Penalties, Permanent Injunction, Monetary Relief, and Other Relief and, together with Fluent, filed a Joint Motion for Entry of Proposed Stipulated Order in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida. The FTC Consent Order was entered by the Court on August 11, 2023, and the escrow funds were released on August 15, 2023. The Company maintains insurance policies that cover certain legal costs, which include those incurred related to the FTC investigation. As of September 30, 2023, the Company had recognized $5,799 as contra-expense to general and administrative expenses with a remaining current asset of $1,777 related to these insurance policies.

FLUENT, INC.

NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (CONTINUED)

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

On October 6, 2020, the Company received notice from the Pennsylvania Office of the Attorney General ("PAAG") that it was reviewing the Company’s business practices relating to telemarketing. After the Company and the PAAG were unable to reach agreement on a proposed Assurance of Voluntary Compliance, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania filed a complaint for permanent injunction, civil penalties, and other relief in the United States District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania on November 2, 2022. On May 18, 2023, the parties entered into a settlement and jointly filed a Consent Petition of Final Decree, wherein the Company agreed to injunctive relief and to pay the PAAG $250 for investigatory costs, all of which was paid as of June 30, 2023.

The Company has been involved in a Telephone Consumer Protection Act class action, Daniel Berman v. Freedom Financial Network, which was originally filed in 2018. On May 31, 2023, the parties entered into an Amended Class Action Settlement Agreement (the "Berman Settlement Agreement"), which includes injunctive provisions and payment to plaintiffs of $9,750 for legal fees and a consumer redress fund. On July 28, 2023, the Court preliminarily approved the Berman Settlement Agreement, and the Company contributed $3,100, payable following the final approval of the settlement. The final approval of the settlement is expected in mid-2024. The Company’s contribution amounts were accrued as of  December 31, 2022. This amount is payable $1,100 in cash and $2,000 pursuant to an interest-bearing note with a two-year term provided by co-defendant, Freedom Financial Network.

11. Business acquisition

True North Acquisition

On  January 1, 2022, the Company acquired a 100% membership interest in True North Loyalty, LLC for a deemed purchase price of $2,321, which consisted of (i) $1,000 in cash at closing, (ii) $860 of deferred payments due at both the first and second anniversary of the closing date adjusted for net working capital, and (iii) contingent consideration with a fair value at the closing date of $250, payable in common stock based upon the achievement of specified revenue targets over the five-year period following the completion of the acquisition. The Company also issued 100,000 shares of fully-vested common stock to the sellers valued at $211. Certain seller parties entered into employment and non-competition agreements with the Company in connection with the True North Acquisition. True North Loyalty, LLC is a subscription-based business that utilizes call center operations and other media channels to market recurring revenue services to consumers. In accordance with ASC 805, the Company determined that the True North Acquisition constituted the purchase of a business.

Since January 1, 2022, the Company has used the excess earnings method, a variation of the income approach, to amortize: (i) the fair value of the acquired customer relationships related to subscribers of $170 over a one-year period and (ii) the fair value of the acquired customer relationships related to call centers of $1,180, over a five-year period. The amount of the purchase price in excess of the fair value of the net assets acquired was recorded as goodwill in the amount of $1,092 and primarily relates to intangible assets that do not qualify for separate recognition, including assembled workforce and synergies. For tax purposes, the goodwill is not deductible.

FLUENT, INC.

NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS (CONTINUED)

(Amounts in thousands, except share and per share data)

(unaudited)

12. Variable Interest Entity

A VIE is an entity that either (i) has insufficient equity to permit the entity to finance its activities without additional subordinated financial support, or (ii) has equity investors who lack the characteristics of a controlling financial interest. The primary beneficiary is the party that has the power to direct activities that most significantly impact the operations of the VIE and has the obligation to absorb losses or the right to benefits from the VIE that could potentially be significant to the VIE. The Company assesses whether we are the primary beneficiary of a VIE at the inception of the arrangement and as of the reporting date.

On January 9, 2023, the Company entered into employment agreements with certain key employees of TAPP, an influencer-based business, which uses as an application to utilize its relationship with influencers to bring consumers to advertising clients. The Company is also a customer of TAPP and accounts for the majority of TAPP’s revenues. By virtue of TAPP’s key employees being employed by the Company and the significance of the Company to TAPP’s financial performance, the Company determined that TAPP qualified as a VIE in which the Company had a variable interest and that the Company is the primary beneficiary as a result of its significant influence and control over certain activities that most significantly impact its economic performance. As a result, the Company consolidates the TAPP operations. As the Company does not have an equity interest, 100% of the net assets and results of the operations of TAPP are attributable to non-controlling interests.

As the Company gained control of TAPP, in accordance with ASC 805, Business Combinations, it was then determined that TAPP constituted a business. The deemed fair value of the consideration was $4,165, which consisted of $1,250 of initial cash and $2,915 which was contingent based upon achievement of specified revenue and media margin targets over three years. The fair value of assets acquired, which excluded the immaterial net-working capital, were determined to be the publisher contracts of $1,100, which were valued using the 'with or without' method, a variation of the income approach, to be amortized over a period of one year and industry-based trade secrets of $1,510, which were valued using the excess earnings method, a variation of the income approach, to be amortized over a period of four years. The amount of the purchase price in excess of the fair value of the net assets acquired was recorded as goodwill in the amount of 1,555 and primarily represents workforce and expected cash flow generation for the TAPP business that does not qualify for separate recognition as intangible assets included within the Fluent operating segment. For tax purposes, the value of the acquisition payments is treated as ordinary compensation for services rendered, deductible when paid and included in the employees’ wages. At and for the nine months ended September 30, 2023, the assets and revenues of TAPP totaled a de minimis percentage of the Company’s total assets and revenue.

Item 2. Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations.

Overview

Fluent, Inc. ("we," "us," "our," "Fluent," or the "Company"), is an industry leader in data-driven digital marketing services. We primarily perform customer acquisition services by operating highly scalable digital marketing campaigns, through which we connect our advertiser clients with consumers they are seeking to reach. We deliver data and performance-based marketing executions to our clients, which include over 500 consumer brands, direct marketers, and agencies across a wide range of industries, including Media & Entertainment, Financial Products & Services, Health & Wellness, Retail & Consumer, and Staffing & Recruitment.

We attract consumers at scale to our owned digital media properties primarily through promotional offerings where they are rewarded for completing activities within our platforms. To register on our sites, consumers provide their names, contact information and opt-in permission to present them with relevant offers on behalf of our clients. Approximately 90% of these users engage with our media on their mobile devices or tablets. Our always-on, real-time capabilities enable users to access our media whenever and wherever they choose.

Once users have registered on our sites, we integrate our proprietary direct marketing technologies to engage them with surveys, polls, and other experiences, through which we gather information about their lifestyles, preferences, purchasing histories and other matters. Based on these insights, we serve targeted, relevant offers to them on behalf of our clients. As new users register and engage on our sites and existing registrants re-engage, the enrichment of our database expands our addressable client base and improves the effectiveness of our performance-based campaigns.

Since our inception, we have amassed a large, proprietary database of first-party, self-declared user information and preferences. We solicit our users’ consent to be contacted by us and/or our advertisers via various contact methods including email, telephone, SMS/text and push messaging. We then leverage their self-declared data in our performance offerings primarily in two ways: (1) to serve advertisements that we believe will be relevant to users based on the information they provide when they engage with our sites, and (2) to provide our clients that purchase access to our data with users' contact information so that such clients may communicate with them directly. We may also leverage our existing technology and database to drive new revenue streams, including syndication models, (e.g., Adflow), and other revenue streams, including utilization-based models (e.g., programmatic advertising).

We generate revenue by delivering measurable online marketing results to our clients. We differentiate ourselves from other marketing alternatives by our abilities to provide clients with a cost-effective and measurable return on advertising spend ("ROAS"), a measure of profitability of sales compared to the money spent on ads, to manage highly targeted and highly fragmented online media sources and to provide access to our owned digital media properties and technology platforms. We are predominantly paid on a negotiated or market-driven "per click," "per lead," or other "per action" basis that aligns with the customer acquisition cost targets of our clients. We bear the costs of sourcing traffic from publishers for our owned digital media properties that ultimately generate qualified clicks, leads, calls, app downloads or customers for our clients.

Through AdParlor, LLC, we conduct our non-core business which offers clients various social media strategies through the planning and buying of media on different platforms.

Third Quarter Financial Summary

Three months ended September 30, 2023, compared to three months ended September 30, 2022:

Nine months ended September 30, 2023, compared to nine months ended September 30, 2022:

Media margin, adjusted EBITDA, and adjusted net income (loss) are non-GAAP financial measures. See "Definitions, Reconciliations and Uses of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" below.

Trends Affecting our Business

Development, Acquisition and Retention of High-Quality Targeted Media Traffic

Our business depends on identifying and accessing media sources that are of high quality and on our ability to attract targeted users to our media properties. As our business has grown, we have attracted larger and more sophisticated clients to our platform. To further increase our value proposition to clients and to fortify our leadership position in the evolving regulatory landscape of our industry, we implemented a Traffic Quality Initiative in 2020. Generating high quality traffic will remain a focus moving forward, and it is now part of a broader initiative to improve the consumer experience.

Starting in 2022, we increased our spend with major digital media platforms, revised our bidding strategies for affiliate traffic, and developed partnerships to expand traffic from social media platforms, including the growing influencer sector. We also pursued strategic initiatives that enable us to grow revenue with existing user traffic volume, while attracting users to our media properties via email and SMS messages. These efforts have continued in 2023, as we continue to focus on improved monetization of consumer traffic through improved customer relationship management and internal capabilities that allow us to re-engage consumers who have registered on our owned media properties. Through these initiatives, our business has become less dependent on the volume of users to generate revenue growth.

We believe that significant value has been, and will continue to be, created by improving the quality of traffic sourced to our media properties, through increased user participation rates on our sites, leading to higher conversion rates, resulting in increased monetization, and ultimately increasing revenue and media margin. Media margin, a non-GAAP measure, is the portion of gross profit (exclusive of depreciation and amortization) reflecting variable costs paid for media and related expenses and excluding non-media cost of revenue.

Since 2022, we have experienced challenges growing our traffic volume because of several factors including the volatility of affiliate supply sources, changes in search engine algorithms, email and text message blocking algorithms, and increased competition for available media. In response to these challenges, we invested in strategic internal efforts to secure additional traffic from social media, including the growing influencer sector and Adflow, our e-commerce post-sales solution. The mix and profitability of our media channels, strategies, and partners is likely to continue to be dynamic and reflect evolving market trends and the regulatory environment.

Advertiser Trends & Seasonality

We deliver data and performance-based marketing executions to our clients across a wide range of industries, including Media & Entertainment, Financial Products & Services, Health & Wellness, Retail & Consumer, and Staffing & Recruitment. Both data and performance-based spend continued to be challenged in 2023 by general economic uncertainty. We experienced slowdowns in the first nine-months of 2023 in certain sectors of the Media & Entertainment, Staffing & Recruitment, and Financial Products & Services industries. Additionally, in the third quarter of 2023 our largest client in the gaming sector pulled back pricing and spend as they refocused on ROAS rather than growth. Although the Company is addressing this pullback by scaling other clients in the marketplace from the gaming sector and other sectors of the Media & Entertainment industry, the gap was not fully absorbed by other bidders.

To offset these challenges, we continue to work with a select group of advertisers to define high performing consumer segments and strategically price paid conversions to help clients drive higher ROAS. This initiative has driven increased budgets from clients in the Media & Entertainment industry, which, collectively, represents a large component of our revenue mix.

Additionally, our results are subject to fluctuations as a result of seasonality and cyclicality in our clients’ businesses. Specifically, Adflow and our businesses that benefit from Medicare and ACA open enrollment benefit from strong fourth quarters. Other factors affecting our business may include macroeconomic conditions that impact the digital advertising industry, the various client verticals we serve, and general market conditions.

Business Practices & Compliance

During the current fiscal year, we continued to be impacted by slowing economic conditions and uncertainty. Additionally, as a result of the FTC Consent Order described in Part II, Item 1 – Legal Proceedings, below, we made additional changes to our employment opportunities marketplace and programmatic advertising businesses and have implemented industry-leading compliance measures across the entire business, which have had negative impacts on our revenues and media margin in the third quarter of 2023. In the medium term, although there can be no assurance, we expect that the increased industry-wide regulatory scrutiny will eliminate the competitive advantage that less compliance-focused competitors currently enjoy as a result of the changes we have implemented, and that our industry-leading compliance will be a competitive advantage enabling us to recapture market share from our competitors. Additionally, our legal fees related to the FTC Consent Order have continued to decrease, and we received an insurance reimbursement for prior legal fees incurred. In response to the regulatory requirements, we will continue to refocus investment into businesses unaffected by the FTC Consent Order, such as the Rewards and Adflow businesses.

Current Economic Conditions

We are subject to risks and uncertainties caused by events with significant macroeconomic impacts. Inflation, rising interest rates and reduced consumer confidence have caused our clients and their customers to be cautious in their spending. The full impact of these macroeconomic events and the extent to which these macro factors may impact our business, financial condition, and results of operations in the future remains uncertain. In light of the challenging macro-economic environment, we have reviewed our strategic investments for 2023 and paused or eliminated lower priority projects while also streamlining our organization through targeted workforce reductions.

Please see Item 1A. Risk Factors in the 2022 Form 10-K, for more information or further discussion of the possible impact of unfavorable conditions on our business.

Definitions, Reconciliations and Uses of Non-GAAP Financial Measures

We report the following non-GAAP measures:

Media margin is defined as that portion of gross profit (exclusive of depreciation and amortization) reflecting the variable costs paid for media and related expenses and excluding non-media cost of revenue. Gross profit (exclusive of depreciation and amortization) represents revenue minus cost of revenue (exclusive of depreciation and amortization). Media margin is also presented as percentage of revenue.

Adjusted EBITDA is defined as net income (loss) excluding (1) income taxes, (2) interest expense, net, (3) depreciation and amortization, (4) share-based compensation expense, (5) goodwill impairment, (6) write-off of intangible assets, (7) loss (gain) on disposal of property and equipment, (8) acquisition-related costs, (9) restructuring and other severance costs, and (10) certain litigation and other related costs.

Adjusted net income (loss) is defined as net income (loss) excluding (1) share-based compensation expense, (2) goodwill impairment, (3) write-off of intangible assets, (4) loss (gain) on disposal of property and equipment (5) acquisition-related costs, (6) restructuring and other severance costs, and (7) certain litigation and other related costs. Adjusted net income (loss) is also presented on a per share (basic and diluted) basis.

Below is a reconciliation of media margin from gross profit (exclusive of depreciation and amortization) for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, respectively, which we believe is the most directly comparable GAAP measure:

Below is a reconciliation of adjusted EBITDA from net income (loss) for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, respectively, which we believe is the most directly comparable GAAP measure:

Below is a reconciliation of adjusted net income (loss) and adjusted net income (loss) per share from net income (loss) for the three and nine months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, respectively, which we believe is the most directly comparable GAAP measure.

We present media margin, media margin as a percentage of revenue, adjusted EBITDA, adjusted net income (loss), and adjusted net income (loss) per share as supplemental measures of our financial and operating performance because we believe they provide useful information to investors. More specifically:

Media margin, as defined above, is a measure of the efficiency of the Company’s operating model. We use media margin and the related measure of media margin as a percentage of revenue as primary metrics to measure the financial return on our media and related costs, specifically to measure the degree by which the revenue generated from our digital marketing services exceeds the cost to attract the consumers to whom offers are made through our services. Media margin is used extensively to manage our operating performance, including evaluating operational performance against budgeted media margin and understanding the efficiency of our media and related expenditures. We also use media margin for performance evaluations and compensation decisions regarding certain personnel.

Adjusted EBITDA, as defined above, is another primary metric by which we evaluate the operating performance of our business, on which certain operating expenditures and internal budgets are based and by which, in addition to media margin and other factors, our senior management is compensated. The first three adjustments represent the conventional definition of EBITDA, and the remaining adjustments are items recognized and recorded under GAAP in particular periods but might be viewed as not necessarily coinciding with the underlying business operations for the periods in which they are so recognized and recorded. These adjustments include certain litigation and other related costs associated with legal matters outside the ordinary course of business, including costs and accruals related to matters as described below (See Part II, Item 1 — Legal Proceedings). We consider items one-time in nature if they are non-recurring, infrequent or unusual and have not occurred in the past two years or are not expected to recur in the next two years, in accordance with SEC rules. There were no adjustments for one-time items in the periods presented by this Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q.

Adjusted net income (loss), as defined above, and the related measure of adjusted net income (loss) per share exclude certain items that are recognized and recorded under GAAP in particular periods but might be viewed as not necessarily coinciding with the underlying business operations for the periods in which they are so recognized and recorded. We believe adjusted net income (loss) affords investors a different view of the overall financial performance as compared to adjusted EBITDA and the GAAP measure of net income (loss).

Media margin, adjusted EBITDA, adjusted net income (loss), and adjusted net income (loss) per share are non-GAAP financial measures with certain limitations regarding their usefulness. They do not reflect our financial results in accordance with GAAP, as they do not include the impact of certain expenses that are reflected in our consolidated statements of operations. Accordingly, these metrics are not indicative of our overall results or indicators of past or future financial performance. Further, they are not financial measures of profitability and are neither intended to be used as a proxy for the profitability of our business nor to imply profitability. The way we measure media margin, adjusted EBITDA, and adjusted net income (loss) may not be comparable to similarly titled measures presented by other companies and may not be identical to corresponding measures used in our various agreements.

Comparison of Our Results of Operations for the Three and Nine Months Ended September 30, 2023 and 2022

Revenue

Three months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the three months ended September 30, 2022

Revenue for the three months ended September 30, 2023 decreased $22.8 million, or 26%, to $66.2 million, compared to $89.0 million for the three months ended September 30, 2022. The decrease was largely attributable to declines in the US Rewards business due to a reduction in client spend. In addition, revenue from the employment opportunities marketplace declined due to the changes in business practices that reflect the recently imposed regulatory requirements in connection with the FTC Consent Order described in Part II, Item 1 – Legal Proceedings, below. 

Nine months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the nine months ended September 30, 2022

Revenue for the nine months ended September 30, 2023 decreased $50.8 million, or 18%, to $225.6 million, compared to $276.5 million for the nine months ended September 30, 2022. The decrease was largely attributable to declines in the US Rewards business due to a reduction in client spend. In addition, revenue from the employment opportunities marketplace declined due to decreased demand related to the slowing labor market and changes in business practices that reflect the recently imposed regulatory requirements in connection with the FTC Consent Order described in Part II, Item 1 – Legal Proceedings, below. The revenue decline was partially offset by growth in our Influencer based platform and new initiatives. 

Cost of revenue (exclusive of depreciation and amortization)

Three months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the three months ended September 30, 2022

Cost of revenue for the three months ended September 30, 2023 (exclusive of depreciation and amortization) decreased $15.1 million, or 23%, to $50.1 million, compared to $65.3 million for the three months ended September 30, 2022. The decrease was attributable to the same factors causing the decline in revenue for the quarter over quarter period. Our cost of revenue primarily consists of media and related costs associated with acquiring traffic from third-party publishers and digital media platforms for our owned and operated websites. The costs also include enablement costs associated with our call centers and tracking costs related to our consumer data. In addition, there are indirect costs which include fulfillment costs related to rewards earned by consumers who complete the requisite number of advertiser offers, along with call center software and hosting costs.

The total cost of revenue for the three months ended September 30, 2023 (exclusive of depreciation and amortization) as a percentage of revenue increased to 76% compared to 73% for the three months ended September 30, 2022. The increase was largely attributable to the increase in the cost of media as a percentage of revenue.

Nine months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the nine months ended September 30, 2022

Cost of revenue for the nine months ended September 30, 2023 (exclusive of depreciation and amortization) decreased $34.9 million, or 17% to $168.0 million, compared to $202.9 million for the nine months ended September 30, 2022. The decrease was primarily attributable to the same factors causing the decline in revenue for the year over year period. The total cost of revenue for the nine months ended September 30, 2023(exclusive of depreciation and amortization) as a percentage of revenue increased to 74% compared to 73% for the nine months ended September 30, 2022. The increase was largely attributable to the increase in the cost of media as a percentage of revenue.

In the normal course of executing paid media campaigns to source consumer traffic, we regularly evaluate new channels, strategies, and partners, in an effort to identify actionable opportunities which can then be optimized over time. Traffic acquisition costs incurred with the major digital media platforms have historically been higher than affiliate traffic sources. For the nine months ended September 30, 2023, digital media spend continued to be driven by strategic test and learn initiatives that began in the second quarter of 2022. The mix and profitability of our media channels, strategies, and partners will likely reflect evolving market dynamics and the impact of our Traffic Quality Initiative and the increased compliance obligations as a result of the FTC Consent Order. As we evaluate and scale new media channels, strategies, and partners, we may determine that certain sources initially able to provide us profitable quality traffic may not be able to maintain our quality standards over time, and we may need to discontinue, or direct a modification of the practices of, such sources, which could reduce profitability. The improved traffic quality being sourced is the foundation to support sustainable long-term growth and positioning us as an industry leader. Past levels of cost of revenue (exclusive of depreciation and amortization) may therefore not be indicative of future costs, which may increase or decrease as these uncertainties in our business play out.

Sales and marketing

Three months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the three months ended September 30, 2022

Sales and marketing expenses for the three months ended September 30, 2023 increased $0.2 million, or 4%, to $4.4 million, compared to $4.3 million for the three months ended September 30, 2022. For the three months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, sales and marketing expense consisted mainly of employee salaries and benefits of $3.9 million and $3.6 million, advertising costs of $0.1 and $0.3 million, and non-cash share-based compensation expenses of $0.1 and $0.1 million, respectively. The increase was primarily due to salary increases partially offset by lower marketing costs incurred.

Nine months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the nine months ended September 30, 2022

Sales and marketing expenses for the nine months ended September 30, 2023 increased $0.9 million, or 7%, to $13.5 million, compared to $12.6 million for the nine months ended September 30, 2022. For the nine months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, sales and marketing expense consisted mainly of employee salaries and benefits of $11.4 million and $10.7 million, advertising costs of $0.7 and $0.8 million, non-cash share-based compensation expenses of $0.4 and $0.4 million, and travel and entertainment of $0.3 and $0.3 million, respectively. The increase was primarily due to salary increases partially offset by reductions in advertising costs.

Product development

Three months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the three months ended September 30, 2022

Product development expense for the three months ended September 30, 2023 decreased $0.1 million, or 2%, to $4.5 million, compared to $4.6 million for the three months ended September 30, 2022. For the three months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, product and development expense consisted mainly of salaries and benefits of $3.4 million and $3.3 million, software license and maintenance costs of $0.5 million and $0.4 million, professional fees of $0.3 million and $0.6 million, and non-cash share-based compensation expense of $0.2 million and $0.1 million, respectively. The decrease in product development expense is primarily due to lower consulting fees.

Nine months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the nine months ended September 30, 2022

Product development expense for the nine months ended September 30, 2023 increased $0.1 million, or 1%, to $14.1 million, compared to $14.0 million for the nine months ended September 30, 2022. For the nine months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, product and development expense consisted mainly of salaries and benefits of $10.3 million and $10.1 million, software license and maintenance costs of $1.4 million and $1.2 million, professional fees of $1.3 million and $2.0 million, and non-cash share-based compensation expense of $0.5 million and $0.4 million, respectively. The slight increase in product development expenses reflects an increase in software license and maintenance costs and other operating costs, mainly offset by the decline in consulting fees.

General and administrative

Three months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the three months ended September 30, 2022

General and administrative expenses for the three months ended September 30, 2023 decreased $2.2 million, or 20%, to $8.7 million, compared to $10.9 million for the three months ended September 30, 2022. For the three months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, general and administrative expense consisted mainly of employee salaries and benefits of $4.4 million and $5.1 million, professional fees of $2.1 million and $1.6 million, office overhead of $1.0 million and $1.1 million, non-cash share-based compensation expense of $0.7 million and $0.6 million, software license and maintenance costs of $0.7 million and $0.6 million, acquisition-related costs of $0.5 million and $0.5 million, and certain litigation and related costs of  ($1.6)million and $0.5 million, respectively. The decrease was mainly the result of a decrease in litigation related costs due to insurance reimbursements of previously incurred legal fees related to the FTC Consent Order and lower salaries due to a decline of headcount and certain employee salary reductions, partially offset by increased consulting fees.

Nine months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the nine months ended September 30, 2022

General and administrative expenses for the nine months ended September 30, 2023 decreased $8.9 million, or 26%, to $25.0 million, compared to $33.9 million for the nine months ended September 30, 2022. For the nine months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, general and administrative expense consisted mainly of employee salaries and benefits of $13.9 million and $16.0 million, professional fees of $5.0 million and $4.3 million, office overhead of $3.2 million and $3.4 million, non-cash share-based compensation expense of $2.1 million and $1.8 million, software license and maintenance costs of $1.9 million and $1.8 million, acquisition-related costs of $1.7 million and $1.7 million, and certain litigation and related costs of  ($6.0) million and $2.5 million, respectively. The decrease was mainly the result of a decline in litigation related costs due to the lower-than-expected regulatory settlement reached in the second quarter of 2023, even as legal fees had increased to reach the settlement, along with insurance reimbursements for previously incurred legal fees related to the FTC Consent Order and lower salary costs due to restructuring in the first quarter of 2023 and fourth quarter of 2022. These increases were partially offset by increased consulting fees and strategic employee training expenses. 

During the first quarter of 2023, the Company implemented reductions in the workforce that resulted in the termination of approximately 20 employees. These reductions in workforce were implemented following management’s determination to reduce headcount and decrease the Company's overhead to more effectively align resources to the Company's core business operations. In connection with these reductions in workforce, the Company incurred $0.5 million in exit-related restructuring costs, consisting primarily of one-time termination benefits and associated costs, to be fully settled in cash by March 31, 2024. 

Depreciation and amortization

Three months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the three months ended September 30, 2022

Depreciation and amortization expenses for the three months ended September 30, 2023 decreased $0.7 million, or 22%, to $2.7 million, compared to $3.4 million for the three months ended September 30, 2022. This decrease was mainly due to certain intangible assets that fully amortized as compared to the three months ended September 30, 2022, partly offset by the amortization of the acquired intangibles related to TAPP Influencers Corp ("TAPP").

Nine months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the nine months ended September 30, 2022

Depreciation and amortization expenses for the nine months ended September 30, 2023 decreased $1.9 million, or 19%, to $8.1 million, compared to $10.0 million for the nine months ended September 30, 2022. This decrease was mainly due to certain intangible assets that had fully amortized as compared to the nine months ended September 30, 2022, partly offset by the amortization of the acquired intangibles related to TAPP.

Goodwill impairment

Three months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the three months ended September 30, 2022

For the three months ended September 30, 2023, the Company recognized $29.7 of goodwill impairment related to both the Fluent and All Other Reporting Unit, compared to none for the three months ended September 30, 2022.

Nine months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the nine months ended September 30, 2022

For the nine months ended September 30, 2023, the Company recognized a $55.4 million impairment loss related to goodwill related to both the Fluent and All Other Reporting Unit, compared to $55.4 million related to the Fluent reporting unit for the nine months ended September 30, 2022.

Write-off of intangible assets

Three months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the three months ended September 30, 2022

For the three months ended September 30, 2023 and 2022, the Company did not recognize write-offs of intangible assets.

Nine months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the nine months ended September 30, 2022

For the nine months ended September 30, 2023, the Company did not recognize write-offs of intangible assets, compared to $0.1 million for the write-offs of intangible assets related to software developed for internal use for the nine months ended September 30, 2022.

Loss (gain) on disposal of property and equipment

The Company recognized no gain or loss on disposal of property and equipment for the three months ended September 30, 2023, compared to de minimis gain on disposal for the three months ended September 30, 2022.

Interest expense, net

Three months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the three months ended September 30, 2022

Interest expense, net, for the three months ended September 30, 2023 increased $0.4 million, compared to the three months ended September 30, 2022, which was driven by a higher average interest rate on the Term Loan described below under "Liquidity and Capital Resources" below.

Nine months ended September 30, 2023 compared to the nine months ended September 30, 2022

Interest expense, net, for the nine months ended September 30, 2023 increased $1.1 million, compared to the nine months ended September 30, 2022, which was driven by a higher average interest rate on the Term Loan described below under "Liquidity and Capital Resources."

Income (loss) before income taxes